Second Homicide of 2026 Deepens Anguilla’s Crisis: 11 Murders from Last Year Still Without Justice

Follow us on Socials: Facebook and Instagram

Anguilla is facing a deepening public‑safety crisis that can no longer be dismissed or delayed. In 2025, the island recorded 11 homicides — none of which have been solved. Today’s killing marks the second homicide of 2026, reigniting widespread concern about the island’s escalating violence and the justice system’s ability to respond. For a small territory built on close-knit communities, the growing list of unresolved killings raises urgent questions about policing, investigative capacity, and public trust.

Robert M. Clark (Commissioner of Police) speaks on why Policing on a small island like Anguilla presents distinct challenges — from limited forensic capacity to stretched personnel and infrastructure.

Video breakdown: • 01:13 Challenges of Policing on a Small Island • 03:36 Murder and Other Crimes • 04:15 Capacity Challenges and Assistance • 06:23 Forensic Limitations and Collaboration • 09:10 Safety and Politeness on the Island.

Law‑enforcement challenges in small jurisdictions are real, but they are not insurmountable. Limited forensic resources, delays in securing and processing evidence, and dependence on off‑island forensic services often weaken investigations during the most critical early hours. 

Advertisement 

Compounding this is the lack of consistent police presence across multiple districts, which affects response times, community intelligence, and deterrence. Equally significant is the issue of witness cooperation. Fear of retaliation, social pressure, and a lack of confidence in outcomes frequently lead to silence — a silence that can stall even the strongest cases.

Policing in Anguilla remains heavily centralized, with the main station located in The Valley. Yet historically, stations in communities such as Blowing Point and Sandy Ground played a vital role in neighbourhood‑level policing and early intervention. 

Advertisement 

Increasingly, residents are calling for these stations to be reopened and fully staffed — not only to respond to crime, but to restore visible law‑enforcement presence in areas where it is most needed. Research consistently shows that proximity policing builds trust, encourages information sharing, and reduces the likelihood of violent crime taking root.

The consequences of inaction extend far beyond individual tragedies. A pattern of unsolved homicides erodes public confidence, emboldens offenders, and threatens Anguilla’s social stability and international reputation. As violence rises, so does the cost of doing nothing. 

Anguilla had a 0% homicide clearance rate for the year 2025 — a rare and troubling statistic for any jurisdiction, especially one as small and tightly knit as Anguilla.

This moment demands transparency, investment in investigative capacity, and renewed collaboration between law enforcement and the communities they serve. Without decisive action, Anguilla risks allowing violence to become normalized — a shift far harder to reverse than to prevent.

📣 Share this story from ALL ANGLES UK:

← Back to Main Page